WritingDraft critique

Get a structural critique of my draft before I publish

Use for a candid editorial review of structure, clarity, and argument before you finalize a piece.

The prompt
prompt.txt
You are a developmental editor giving an honest pre-publish critique.

Draft:
"""
{{draft}}
"""

Intended audience and goal: {{audience_and_goal}}

Critique it across:
1. STRUCTURE: does it open well, flow logically, and end strongly?
2. CLARITY: where will a reader get confused or lost?
3. ARGUMENT/POINT: is the core point clear and supported?
4. ENGAGEMENT: where does it drag or lose energy?
5. CUTS: name 3 things to remove.

Rules:
- Be specific; quote the lines you mean.
- Prioritize the top 3 fixes that would most improve it.
- Do not rewrite the whole thing; diagnose. No long dashes.

Click the copy button in the top right of the block to grab the full prompt.

Variables

Replace each placeholder below with your own values before you run the prompt.

  • {{draft}}
  • {{audience_and_goal}}
Recommended models
Claude Opus 4.8GPT-5Gemini 2.5 Pro
Tags
#editing#critique#developmental#feedback

Related prompts

WritingClarity rewrite
Rewrite a paragraph to be clearer

You are a plain-language editor. Rewrite the text below so it is clearer and easier to read. Keep the original meaning, facts, and intent exactly. Do not add new information. Rules...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5Gemini 2.5 Pro
#rewriting#clarity#editing
View
WritingSummarize text
Summarize a long document

Summarize the document below for a reader who has not seen it. Produce: 1. A one-sentence summary (the single most important takeaway). 2. {{bullet_count}} bullet points covering t...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5Gemini 2.5 Pro
#summarizing#notes#research
View
WritingEdit email
Polish a professional email

You are an executive communications editor. Improve the email draft below. Keep my core message and any specific facts, names, and dates intact. Goals: - Make the ask or purpose ob...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5Gemini 2.5 Flash
#email#editing#tone
View
WritingDraft email
Write a cold outreach email

Write a cold outreach email from me to {{recipient}}. Context about me / my offer: {{my_context}} Why I am reaching out to this specific person: {{personal_hook}} The one action I...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5
#email#outreach#persuasion
View
WritingAdjust tone
Change the tone of any text

Rewrite the text below to match a new tone, without changing the underlying message or facts. Current tone: {{current_tone}} Desired tone: {{desired_tone}} Audience: {{audience}} G...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5Gemini 2.5 Pro
#tone#rewriting#editing
View
WritingCopy edit
Copy edit for grammar and style

Act as a meticulous copy editor following {{style_guide}} style. Copy edit the text below. Fix grammar, spelling, punctuation, and clunky phrasing. Preserve the author's voice and...

Claude Opus 4.xGPT-5Gemini 2.5 Pro
#copy-editing#grammar#proofreading
View

0 Comments

Sign in to post

Loading discussion...