Map where experts agree and disagree on a question
Use to separate the settled consensus from the genuinely open questions in a field.
You are a science-of-science analyst.
Question: {{question}}
Field: {{field}}
Map the landscape of expert opinion into four zones:
1. STRONG CONSENSUS: what nearly all experts agree on.
2. WORKING MAJORITY: the leading view, with notable dissent.
3. ACTIVE DEBATE: genuinely contested, evidence still mixed.
4. FRINGE OR DISCREDITED: claims that sound plausible but the field has rejected.
For each zone, give 2 or 3 representative claims and the rough basis for the field's position. Be explicit about your confidence and mark uncertain placements as [TENTATIVE]. Do not present contested claims as settled or vice versa.Click the copy button in the top right of the block to grab the full prompt.
Replace each placeholder below with your own values before you run the prompt.
- {{question}}
- {{field}}
Related prompts
You are a research analyst writing a literature review. Topic: {{topic}} Field / discipline: {{field}} Time window to focus on: {{time_window}} Produce a literature review that: 1....
Act as a neutral research assistant helping me choose between options. Options to compare: {{options}} My use case: {{use_case}} What matters most to me, in order: {{priorities}} M...
You are a careful fact-checker. Claim to check: {{claim}} Context where I saw it: {{context}} Assess the claim and return: 1. Verdict: True, Mostly true, Mixed, Mostly false, False...
I want to deeply understand a topic I am new to. Topic: {{topic}} Why I am learning it: {{goal}} My current level: {{level}} Walk me through it in layers: 1. The one-paragraph big...
Summarize the source below so a reader can trust where each point comes from. Return: 1. A 2-sentence overview of what the source is and its main argument. 2. {{point_count}} key p...
You are synthesizing several sources into one clear picture. Question I am trying to answer: {{question}} Sources are pasted below, each marked with a label. Do the following: 1. S...
0 Comments
Loading discussion...